I add the following with no comments:
 
".... There are few glaring mistakes in this article. UN was not the only place Tharoor worked before the becoming the Minister at MEA. He was the chairman of a Private equity fund out of Dubai. The author in this artcile does not mention how Tharoor got elected, who funded his campaign and also who funded his famous hotel stay in Delhi for 3 months after he became the minister.
Hillary Clinton was never Tharoors counter part, he was the Under secretary, in no protocol no matter how over proud and over hyped Indians and Indian press are he was never on the same level as US Secretary of State. In case the author does not know US has a cabinet position as UN Ambassador.
Tharoor hyped his profile at the UN and got Indian backing via his backers in New Delhi to run for the UN secretary Generals position, which if any one cares to talk with the UN folks was a crazy idea and Crazier for Indian Govt to support it. But that was a ego play than anything else.
He then was air dropped into Indian politics, he played the same game as any other politician, manipulated to get a weak communist candidate and got elected. Then he was ushered into Ministry.
The mistake that he made was, he never understood the "business plan" and especially the "revenue model" of an Indian Minister. He just tried to gate crash into domains he was not invited in the first place.
Is he clean, i do not think so, but is he better than the rest, in many ways sure. I have no sympathy for him, he was naive and he thought he can do anything with his charisma. Still I wish him the best...  "

Agni

 

---

From: ajandhyala@hotmail.com
To: ajandhyala@hotmail.com
Subject: FW: Who is Shashi Tharoor?
Date: Tue, 20 Apr 2010 11:07:14 -0400


 

---

Date: Sat, 17 Apr 2010 16:26:31 +0000
To: raja.karthikeya@gmail.com; s.sadagopan@gmail.com; srayapro@gmail.com; s_aditham@yahoo.com; aditham@gmail.com; Adiseshavataram.Cherukupalli@gmrgroup.in; suneel53@yahoo.co.in; vsrsastry@rediffmail.com; kaivalyarayaprolu@gmail.com
Subject: Who is Shashi Tharoor?
From: valliswar@rediffmail.com
CC: ajandhyala@hotmail.com; drsuryaraok@gmail.com; ganbhukta@gmail.com; gatturadha@gmail.com; lavagarwal@hotmail.com; lankavs@rediffmail.com; k.sudhakargoud@gmail.com; nvrlnrao@hotmail.com; akshiran@yahoo.com; sudhanambudiri@rediffmail.com

Note: Forwarded message attached

-- Original Message --

From: nair madhavan amadhavannair@yahoo.co.uk

Subject: Who is Shashi Tharoor?


--Forwarded Message Attachment--
From: amadhavannair@yahoo.co.uk
Subject: Who is Shashi Tharoor?
To: p.ramanujan@gmail.com; k_ashwinnair@yahoo.co.in; ashes_kitts@yahoo.com; rbijunair@hotmail.com; chalat_chandran@hotmail.com; cpw@binanizinc.co.in; cknandu@binanizinc.co.in; valliswar@rediffmail.com; vijayp_nair@hotmail.com; linsur@yahoo.com; nairmns1942@yahoo.com; ramanujan.suresh@emersonprocess.com

The thoughts, views, opinions and perspectives of Iktara World Chief Executive Shiraz Gidwani, encompassing international affairs, observations from travels around the world and at home in Dubai. Who is Shashi Tharoor? Posted by shirazgidwani in General on April 16th, 2010 WHAT HAPPENS WHEN AN EXAMPLE IS MADE THE EXCEPTION When I turned on the television, when I refreshed my twitter or when I checked my BlackBerry Messenger, only one question seemed pertinent; do these people truly know Shashi Tharoor? Over the months gone by, the Indian Union Minister of State for External Affairs, Dr. Shashi Tharoor has been repeatedly in the public eye, but hardly ever about his accomplishments and undertakings or his unrelenting efforts at building relations with foreign countries. If I defend him, it will appear partial and if I cringe at the horrendous allegations against him, it will be alleged that my judgement is clouded. Therefore, allow me to take you on a short journey as we delve into the life of Shashi Tharoor. It will allow you to decide who he really is. Education When Shashi Tharoor graduated with the Robert B. Stewart prize for best student from the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy (a joint campus between the prestigious Harvard and Tufts Universities), he walked out with PhD laurels resting on his 22 year old shoulders. To have earned a bachelors degree from St. Stephens College, Delhi (where he was also President of the College Union), two masters degrees and a PhD by the tender age of 22, were the stepping stones in the making of a man who would go on to be the best-selling prize-winning author of 10 fiction and non-fiction books. Transition Imagine this: you work in one place for 30 years of your life. That was your first place of work and has remained your only identity for the entirety of your adult life. Suddenly, you transition into new surroundings, encounter new colleagues (some with contrasting approaches and opinions) and a distinctly different working culture. It would take a few months to adjust to the new environment, a short while to get your bearings, right? Shashi Tharoor worked for the United Nations for 29 years. It was his first place of work and until now, his only. Shouldn’t we have afforded him some time to settle into the system and understand the environment he now finds himself in? His relationship with the media has been contrary to what I expected. At the United Nations, I recall with fondness how the press and media adored him. He was elevated to the second-highest rank in the UN system by Kofi Annan because of his mastery of the external communications of the organisation. Contrast that to the present day where you know a new month has started because Shashi Tharoor is in the news. The Person Jacob Joseph forfeited a lucrative career in the United Arab Emirates and stepped in to be a driving force as we geared up the 2009 campaign to Parliament. When Shashi Tharoor became an MP and the MP became a Minister, he understandably offered Jacob the position of Officer on Special Duty (OSD) in New Delhi. That Jacob accepted the offer, relocated his family and home and rolled up his sleeves to face the Indian bureaucratic system speaks volumes about the belief and faith those around him have in Shashi Tharoor. But for arguments sake, lets be disparaging here. Jacob is from the Minister’s home state of Kerala, so he could be excused for looking up to his MP and now Minister of State for External Affairs. The same though cannot be said for Sandeep Chakravorty. Sandeep – a career officer – requested a special transfer to be able to work with the dynamic and charismatic Shashi Tharoor as his Private Secretary. Sandeep certainly isn’t from Kerala. I have spent quality time with both of them and am privileged to call them both friends. But outside of our friendship, I have seen the passion and drive that they have for what they do and the man they work with, a warmth and affection I have seen equally reciprocated by the Minister himself. Shouldn’t this be the winning solution we celebrate as ideal and try to replicate across the Ministries of the Government of India? As for the Minister himself, Shashi Tharoor doesn’t just wear the Indian flag pinned to his heart on hisbandhgala. He is a true and proud Indian who sacrificed a sizeable salary and all the luxuries in the world to make a difference to India. The same man who never accepted British citizenship, despite the fact that he was born there. What does Shashi Tharoor mean to India? For starters, he has spent 29 years building relationships with foreign leaders. These leaders are now instantly nearer and dearer friends of India. Not only does he share personal friendships with them, he converses with them in diction and an oratory prowess far superior to any Indian politician I have encountered in my short life.  And if you thought his English parlance is refined, the man speaks impeccable French (I am apparently fluent and cannot keep up with him). So his conversations with francophone leaders are of a more warm and personal nature. India has spent years courting a relationship with the United States, but Shashi Tharoor and his counterpart Hilary Clinton go back to the days of her husband’s presidency when she was First Lady and he was Under-Secretary-General of the United Nations. If nothing else, we finally have a Minister we can be proud to present to the world. A man of great sophistication, elegance & poise and yet enough embedded in his ‘Great Indian Mind’ to converse intellectually for hours on any topic whatsoever. I remember the first time I was to travel with him, we met for a briefing in his New York office at United Nations Headquarters. Alan Jarus, his then Personal Assistant made it clear to me that, “this is a man who believes in packing 80 seconds into every minute”. So many years later, whether it was hustling around his South Block office, frantically catching up on mail, messages and tweets from the car or hurriedly packing at home for an official travel engagement, I saw the same Shashi Tharoor packing 80 seconds into every minute. I think you would be hard pressed to find a Minister quite like that in India today. Shashi Tharoor’s return to India after a distinguished and celebrated career – which culminated at the helm of the United Nations – should have served as a motivator for Indians around the world to repatriate their dexterity to build an India for the future. Instead, the message we continue to send out is that India remains a club with great exclusivity and closed doors. Who is Shashi Tharoor? To me; friend, mentor and one of the greatest leaders and thinkers India has ever produced. A man we should encourage, support and send out to the world to represent us. For a man who believes that “India has always mattered”, to him and who would now, “like to matter to India”, his passion, devotion and commitment should be made the example, not the exception. The author is Chief Executive of Iktara World and Executive Chairman of the Young Leaders Organisation. Shiraz Gidwani is a citizen of India residing in Dubai. He is also the author of ‘Apna Indian Awakening’, and frequent op-eds and columns. The views expressed in this article are the author’s own.

--Forwarded Message Attachment--
From: amadhavannair@yahoo.co.uk
Subject: Who is Shashi Tharoor?
To: p.ramanujan@gmail.com; k_ashwinnair@yahoo.co.in; ashes_kitts@yahoo.com; rbijunair@hotmail.com; chalat_chandran@hotmail.com; cpw@binanizinc.co.in; cknandu@binanizinc.co.in; valliswar@rediffmail.com; vijayp_nair@hotmail.com; linsur@yahoo.com; nairmns1942@yahoo.com; ramanujan.suresh@emersonprocess.com

The thoughts, views, opinions and perspectives of Iktara World Chief Executive Shiraz Gidwani, encompassing international affairs, observations from travels around the world and at home in Dubai. Who is Shashi Tharoor? Posted by shirazgidwani in General on April 16th, 2010 WHAT HAPPENS WHEN AN EXAMPLE IS MADE THE EXCEPTION When I turned on the television, when I refreshed my twitter or when I checked my BlackBerry Messenger, only one question seemed pertinent; do these people truly know Shashi Tharoor? Over the months gone by, the Indian Union Minister of State for External Affairs, Dr. Shashi Tharoor has been repeatedly in the public eye, but hardly ever about his accomplishments and undertakings or his unrelenting efforts at building relations with foreign countries. If I defend him, it will appear partial and if I cringe at the horrendous allegations against him, it will be alleged that my judgement is clouded. Therefore, allow me to take you on a short journey as we delve into the life of Shashi Tharoor. It will allow you to decide who he really is. Education When Shashi Tharoor graduated with the Robert B. Stewart prize for best student from the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy (a joint campus between the prestigious Harvard and Tufts Universities), he walked out with PhD laurels resting on his 22 year old shoulders. To have earned a bachelors degree from St. Stephens College, Delhi (where he was also President of the College Union), two masters degrees and a PhD by the tender age of 22, were the stepping stones in the making of a man who would go on to be the best-selling prize-winning author of 10 fiction and non-fiction books. Transition Imagine this: you work in one place for 30 years of your life. That was your first place of work and has remained your only identity for the entirety of your adult life. Suddenly, you transition into new surroundings, encounter new colleagues (some with contrasting approaches and opinions) and a distinctly different working culture. It would take a few months to adjust to the new environment, a short while to get your bearings, right? Shashi Tharoor worked for the United Nations for 29 years. It was his first place of work and until now, his only. Shouldn’t we have afforded him some time to settle into the system and understand the environment he now finds himself in? His relationship with the media has been contrary to what I expected. At the United Nations, I recall with fondness how the press and media adored him. He was elevated to the second-highest rank in the UN system by Kofi Annan because of his mastery of the external communications of the organisation. Contrast that to the present day where you know a new month has started because Shashi Tharoor is in the news. The Person Jacob Joseph forfeited a lucrative career in the United Arab Emirates and stepped in to be a driving force as we geared up the 2009 campaign to Parliament. When Shashi Tharoor became an MP and the MP became a Minister, he understandably offered Jacob the position of Officer on Special Duty (OSD) in New Delhi. That Jacob accepted the offer, relocated his family and home and rolled up his sleeves to face the Indian bureaucratic system speaks volumes about the belief and faith those around him have in Shashi Tharoor. But for arguments sake, lets be disparaging here. Jacob is from the Minister’s home state of Kerala, so he could be excused for looking up to his MP and now Minister of State for External Affairs. The same though cannot be said for Sandeep Chakravorty. Sandeep – a career officer – requested a special transfer to be able to work with the dynamic and charismatic Shashi Tharoor as his Private Secretary. Sandeep certainly isn’t from Kerala. I have spent quality time with both of them and am privileged to call them both friends. But outside of our friendship, I have seen the passion and drive that they have for what they do and the man they work with, a warmth and affection I have seen equally reciprocated by the Minister himself. Shouldn’t this be the winning solution we celebrate as ideal and try to replicate across the Ministries of the Government of India? As for the Minister himself, Shashi Tharoor doesn’t just wear the Indian flag pinned to his heart on hisbandhgala. He is a true and proud Indian who sacrificed a sizeable salary and all the luxuries in the world to make a difference to India. The same man who never accepted British citizenship, despite the fact that he was born there. What does Shashi Tharoor mean to India? For starters, he has spent 29 years building relationships with foreign leaders. These leaders are now instantly nearer and dearer friends of India. Not only does he share personal friendships with them, he converses with them in diction and an oratory prowess far superior to any Indian politician I have encountered in my short life.  And if you thought his English parlance is refined, the man speaks impeccable French (I am apparently fluent and cannot keep up with him). So his conversations with francophone leaders are of a more warm and personal nature. India has spent years courting a relationship with the United States, but Shashi Tharoor and his counterpart Hilary Clinton go back to the days of her husband’s presidency when she was First Lady and he was Under-Secretary-General of the United Nations. If nothing else, we finally have a Minister we can be proud to present to the world. A man of great sophistication, elegance & poise and yet enough embedded in his ‘Great Indian Mind’ to converse intellectually for hours on any topic whatsoever. I remember the first time I was to travel with him, we met for a briefing in his New York office at United Nations Headquarters. Alan Jarus, his then Personal Assistant made it clear to me that, “this is a man who believes in packing 80 seconds into every minute”. So many years later, whether it was hustling around his South Block office, frantically catching up on mail, messages and tweets from the car or hurriedly packing at home for an official travel engagement, I saw the same Shashi Tharoor packing 80 seconds into every minute. I think you would be hard pressed to find a Minister quite like that in India today. Shashi Tharoor’s return to India after a distinguished and celebrated career – which culminated at the helm of the United Nations – should have served as a motivator for Indians around the world to repatriate their dexterity to build an India for the future. Instead, the message we continue to send out is that India remains a club with great exclusivity and closed doors. Who is Shashi Tharoor? To me; friend, mentor and one of the greatest leaders and thinkers India has ever produced. A man we should encourage, support and send out to the world to represent us. For a man who believes that “India has always mattered”, to him and who would now, “like to matter to India”, his passion, devotion and commitment should be made the example, not the exception. The author is Chief Executive of Iktara World and Executive Chairman of the Young Leaders Organisation. Shiraz Gidwani is a citizen of India residing in Dubai. He is also the author of ‘Apna Indian Awakening’, and frequent op-eds and columns. The views expressed in this article are the author’s own.