EMAIL DETAILS
SUBJECT:
FW: Office of Vice President Biden Intelligence Briefing for Friday, November 9, 2018
PRI: NORMAL
FROM:
K
kchung@vpbiden.org
DATE:
2018-11-09 14:29:05
MSG_ID:
<94f57c66b90a8eff715f0d447aab739a@mail.gmail.com>
RECIPIENTS:
TO:
H
Valerie Biden Owens
<hurricane5155@gmail.com>
J
Jimmy Biden
<jbiden@lionhallgp.com>
J
Jill Tracy Biden
<jill.tracy2@gmail.com>
R
Hunter Biden
<rhbdc@icloud.com>
T
Ashley Blazer Biden
<trailblazerbiden@gmail.com>
CONTENT:
TEXT: YES |
HTML: YES
PROCESSED
Office of Vice President Biden Intelligence Briefing *From:* Bulletin Intelligence <Biden@BulletinIntelligence.com> *Sent:* Friday, November 9, 2018 7:59 AM *To:* Biden@BulletinIntelligence.com *Subject:* Office of Vice President Biden Intelligence Briefing for Friday, November 9, 2018 *Click to access <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=000-d2e&t=c> mobile-optimized online version, including download options and an audio reader.* [image: Image removed by sender. Office of Vice President Biden Intelligence Briefing] <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=001-f00&t=c> *To: Vice President Joe Biden* *Friday, November 9, 2018 8:00 AM EST* Today's Table of Contents *Biden in the News <#SECTION_1>* • Strong Performance In Midwest Bodes Well For Centrist Democratic Candidates In 2020. <#S1> • Biden To Visit Missoula, Montana On Book Tour. <#S2> *Leading the News <#SECTION_2>* • Sources: Whitaker Will Not Recuse Himself From Mueller Probe. <#S3> *Foreign Policy <#SECTION_3>* • Haley: North Korea Postponed Pompeo Meeting. <#S4> • Saudis Ignoring US Ceasefire Calls As Fighting Threatens Hundreds Of Thousands Of Yemenis. <#S5> • US Reportedly Considering Designating Houthis A Terrorist Organization. <#S6> • US Announces More Sanctions Over Russia’s Actions In Ukraine. <#S7> • Reuters Analysis: US Isolation Will Soften Impact Of Renewed Sanctions On Iran. <#S8> • Democrats Set To Demand To Know What Trump Has Said To Putin And Kim. <#S9> • US Destroyer Nearly Collided With A Chinese Warship In September. <#S10> *Domestic Policy <#SECTION_4>* • Afghanistan Veteran Kills 12 In California Bar Before Killing Himself. <#S11> • Ginsburg Hospitalized As Kavanaugh Is Welcomed To Supreme Court. <#S12> • Media Analyses: Sanders Posted Altered Video Of Acosta Incident. <#S13> • Administration Moves To Require Asylum Seekers To Go To Designated Ports Of Entry. <#S14> • Ninth Circuit Rules Trump Cannot End DACA. <#S15> • Canada: US Attempting To Change Texts Of Trade Deal. <#S16> • Reuters Poll: Both Democrats And Republicans Want Congress To Prioritize Healthcare. <#S17> *Cancer Research <#SECTION_5>* • Cigarette Smoking Hits All-Time Low Among Adults, Report Says. <#S18> • Research Confirms Patients With Low-Risk Thyroid Cancer Can Be Safely, Effectively Treated With Low Doses Of Radiotherapy After Surgery. <#S19> *Editorials/Op-Eds <#SECTION_6>* • New York Times. <#S20> • Washington Post. <#S21> Biden in the News Strong Performance In Midwest Bodes Well For Centrist Democratic Candidates In 2020. NBC News <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=002-c08&t=c> (11/9) reports that Democrats “made gains and held critical seats in the Midwestern and Rust Belt states that Donald Trump flipped in 2016, raising hopes that the party can still compete in 2020 and beyond.” Democratic victories in Wisconsin, Minnesota, Michigan, Pennsylvania, and in Ohio, where Sen. Sherrod Brown won re-election by 6.5 points, suggest “there’s room for a Democrat to win with the right brown.” According to NBC News, the results “could bolster the case for potential presidential contenders who have an established appeal with rural and blue-collar voters, like Brown,” Minnesota Sen. Amy Klobuchar, “or former Vice President Joe Biden, over more progressive rivals.” BBC World News (UK) <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=003-4d4&t=c> (11/8) reports on discussions in the Democratic Party “as to whether the party should focus in 2020 on trying to win back the Midwest or trying for a ‘Sunbelt strategy’ that instead built an electoral college majority with the help of states like Florida, North Carolina and Arizona.” The 2018 results support the Midwest strategy, which may cause the party to “cast their eyes is the pride of Scranton in Pennsylvania, Joe Biden.” The former Vice President would be a “serious frontrunner if he decides to enter the race,” considering his “ability to appeal to the Midwest working class – his ability to speak their language and understand their concerns.” The Hill <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=004-c09&t=c> (11/9, Parnes) reports Tuesday’s results “gave conflicting information to Democrats strategizing over whether the party is better off nominating someone like former Vice President Joe Biden, a more centrist candidate with a reputation for appealing to Rust Belt voters, or a progressive firebrand in the mold of Sens. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) or Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.).” One Democratic strategist argued “the more centrist Biden was the more compelling candidate to win Michigan, Wisconsin, Pennsylvania and Ohio.” The strategist explained, “The people who won statewide this week were all able to leave the progressive bubble and put on their moderate hats. ... They ran their campaigns from the political center. That’s why they were successful, full stop.” In a piece highlighting Sen. Sherrod Brown’s successful re-election campaign in Ohio, Yahoo! News <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=005-f87&t=c> (11/9, Correspondent) columnist Andrew Romano notes the “usual suspects” expected to run for president in 2020 include Joe Biden, Bernie Sanders, Elizabeth Warren, and Kamala Harris. *Democrats Expected To Begin Declaring Presidential Bids In “Coming Weeks To Months.” *AFP <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=006-84d&t=c> (11/8, Cuzin) reports that now that Democrats have reclaimed the House and flipped several governorships, multiple Democrats are expected to “declare their presidential bids in the coming weeks to months,” said Democratic strategist Dena Grayson. The list includes “septuagenarians” such as former Vice President Joe Biden, Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT), and Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA), as well as “new faces” like Texas Rep. Beto O’Rourke, California Senator Kamala Harris, and New Jersey Senator Cory Booker, among others. Biden To Visit Missoula, Montana On Book Tour. The Missoula Current (MT) <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=007-b7b&t=c> (11/8) reports former Vice President Joe Biden, “an oft-mentioned potential Democratic presidential candidate in 2020,” announced he is coming to Missoula, Montana on Monday, Dec. 3 as part of his “American Promise” tour. Montana Kaimin <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=008-00d&t=c> (11/8, Ryan OConnell /, Kaimin) reports that according to the event’s Facebook page, Biden will discuss his book “Promise Me Dad: A Year of Hope, Hardship and Purpose.” Missoula will be the first of three stops for Biden, who will visit Grand Prairie, Texas on Dec. 4 and Burlington, Vermont on Dec. 9. KECI-TV[image: Image removed by sender. Video] <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=009-756&t=c> Missoula, MT (11/8, 5:34 a.m. MST) also reported on this story in its morning news broadcast Leading the News Sources: Whitaker Will Not Recuse Himself From Mueller Probe. Amid worries from President Trump’s critics that Acting Attorney General Whitaker could undermine Robert Mueller’s investigation, reports indicate that he has no intention of recusing himself from the probe. For example, the Washington Post <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=00a-e46&t=c> (11/8, Dawsey), citing “people close to” Whitaker, says he “has no intention of recusing himself from overseeing the special counsel probe.” Moreover, the same sources “do not believe he would approve any subpoena of President Trump as part of that investigation.” The Post goes on to report that while serving as Jeff Sessions’ chief of staff, Whitaker “questioned” Deputy AG Rosenstein’s “ability to give Mueller such wide latitude and wanted to explore the bounds of what Mueller was examining.” Townhall <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=00b-1a8&t=c> (11/8, Vespa) similarly indicates that “despite recusal calls, Whitaker is pretty much telling the Democrats to shove it,” and the AP <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=00c-c35&t=c> (11/8, Kellman, Tucker) that he has in the past “warned that...Mueller’s Russia investigation risks ‘going too far’ and supported limits on the prosecutor’s power.” NBC Nightly News[image: Image removed by sender. Video] <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=00d-9b2&t=c> (11/8, story 8, 1:40, Williams) reported, “Justice Department ethics lawyers will now advise Whitaker whether he should recuse from the Russia investigation, but there is no sign he intends to.” The CBS Evening News[image: Image removed by sender. Video] <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=00e-3d9&t=c> (11/8, story 6, 2:10, Reid) also reported “sources tell CBS News [that] Whitaker has no plans to recuse himself, despite calls from Democrats to do so,” and ABC World News Tonight[image: Image removed by sender. Video] <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=00f-4a2&t=c> (11/8, story 6, 2:05, Muir) referred to “a growing outcry over the President’s appointment of a political loyalist to run the Justice Department,” and added that “multiple sources tell ABC News [that] Matt Whitaker will not recuse himself from overseeing the Russia investigation.” The Wall Street Journal <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=010-a1a&t=c> (11/8, Viswanatha, Gurman, Ballhaus) runs a similar analysis, and Reuters <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=011-305&t=c> (11/8, Gibson, Harte) reports that Walter Shaub, “who was director of the U.S. Office of Government Ethics for four years before resigning in July 2017,” believes Whitaker ought to recuse himself from overseeing the Mueller investigation because Whitaker “is a close friend of Trump’s 2016 election campaign co-chair,” Sam Clovis, who has “testified before the grand jury in the Mueller investigation.” Rep. Adam Schiff (D-CA), who is expected to become chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, tweeted <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=012-7b3&t=c>, “Acting AG Whitaker’s relationship with Sam Clovis, an important witness in the Russia probe, and his past prejudicial comments about the investigation warrant his recusal. Congress must determine whether Whitaker made any promises to Trump about his recusal or impeding Mueller.” Bloomberg News <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=013-77c&t=c> (11/8, Pettypiece) reports, however, that Jay Sekulow, one of Trump’s attorneys, says Sessions’ exit “won’t change the course of...Mueller’s investigation.” According to Bloomberg News, Sekulow, “speaking Thursday on his radio show, said there will be ‘no effect day-to-day’ on Mueller with...Whitaker, Sessions’s former chief of staff, in charge.” Bloomberg News adds that Sekulow said “the main difference...will be that Mueller’s confidential report goes to the attorney general now, not...Rosenstein.” Along similar lines, the Washington Post <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=014-50d&t=c> (11/8, Sonmez) reports Senate Majority Leader McConnell “said Thursday that he doesn’t believe...Trump will stop” Mueller’s investigation. McConnell told Kentucky radio station KVLK, “The President has said on multiple occasions the Mueller investigation should be completed. ... He [wishes] it would happen sooner. But I don’t think there’s any chance that the Mueller investigation will not be allowed to finish.” Asked on CNN’s Anderson Cooper 360[image: Image removed by sender. Video] <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=015-644&t=c> (11/8) what surprised the White House most about the reaction to Whitaker, senior White House correspondent Pamela Brown said, “Really, it’s the negative reaction to...Whitaker being appointed by the President as the acting attorney general. This is according to my sources...who say they’re sort of caught off guard by some of the coverage and the fact that he had made these comments publicly on CNN, as well as op-eds where he called the Mueller probe ridiculous, and suggested it could be a fishing expedition, suggested that Mueller was overstepping his bounds. Some officials are saying that they didn’t know he had made these comments, which is ironic, because it was those kinds of comments where Matt Whitaker was saying that he was critical of the Mueller probe that caught the attention of Donald Trump. That’s exactly what Donald Trump liked.” House Minority Leader Pelosi said on CNN’s Cuomo Prime Time[image: Image removed by sender. Video] <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=016-c4c&t=c> (11/8) that the President has been “outspoken in saying he wanted to curtail the Mueller investigation, that it should be curtailed. Article II, Section Two, clause two of the Constitution says that principals in our government like the Attorney General have to be confirmed by the Senate. The President appoints with the confirmation of the Senate. That didn’t happen. You’ve seen some of the quotes today that this appointment makes a mockery of the Constitution and the vision of our founders.” Pelosi added that Whitaker “should not be there because of the statements he’s made already.” On CBS’ Late Show[image: Image removed by sender. Video] <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=017-a91&t=c> (11/9, Colbert), Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY) said she does not think the Whitaker appointment was constitutional. She said, “Because he is in such a senior position, you need advice and consent of the Senate. ... There was a succession plan; it should have been Rosenstein, and they not only disregarded that, they then put someone in place who had not had hearings and approval by the Senate. ... He’s a lackey of the President. He’s been chosen because he is a political pawn.” Sen. Mark Warner (D-VA) said on CNN’s Anderson Cooper 360[image: Image removed by sender. Video] <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=018-baf&t=c> (11/8), “The President could have avoided even any of these questions if he had simply appointed the Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein to be in this temporary position. Instead, he picked this individual, Mr. Whitaker, who, the best asset I can see is he’s a big-time Trump loyalist.” Warner added that Whitaker “has a clear conflict of interest in terms of overseeing any part of the Mueller investigation.” Rep. Schiff said on CNN’s The Lead[image: Image removed by sender. Video] <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=019-718&t=c> (11/8) that is Whitaker “recuse himself...any decision he makes in the Mueller investigation is going to have a taint about it. It’s going to cause a profound question among the public about whether these decisions are being made by the new Attorney General, acting Attorney General in the interest of justice or purely in Donald Trump’s legal liability interests. This is exactly why he ought to recuse himself, and one question that we have here in Congress right now is did he, was he forced somehow to make a commitment to the President to ignore the advice of ethics lawyers at the Justice Department or not seek out their advice? Was that part of his getting the job because this President is guided by one thing alone and that’s what’s good for Donald Trump. The country doesn’t matter that much.” Rep. Jackie Speier (D-CA) said on CNN’s Situation Room[image: Image removed by sender. Video] <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=01a-f17&t=c> (11/8) that Whitaker “is not an independent, unbiased person who is supposed to be meting out justice here. This is someone who has a strong position. ... I also think we should ask the Office of Government Ethics to do an evaluation as to whether or not he is appropriate to hold that position. He should recuse himself. He’s now saying he won’t, but we should demand that that evaluation be done.” Rep. Nanette Barragán (D-CA) tweeted <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=01b-cbc&t=c>, “Whitaker has a record of partisanship and has even suggested the special counsel’s investigation is a ‘witch hunt.’ Congress must take immediate action to protect the Mueller investigation.” Rep. David Cicilline (D-RI) tweeted <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=01c-99c&t=c>, “Matt Whitaker needs to recuse himself now.” Rep. Adriano Espaillat (D-NY) tweeted <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=01d-f2f&t=c>, “Given these past prejudicial comments and conflicts of interest, Acting AG Whitaker must recuse himself from the Mueller investigation. Period.” Rep. Pramila Jayapal (D-WA) tweeted <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=01e-876&t=c>, “To @realDonaldTrump and Matt Whitaker: Americans of all backgrounds will resist any attempt to obstruct justice, and you are #NotAboveTheLaw! My colleagues and I on the Judiciary Committee are now in the majority, and we will do everything in our power to #ProtectMueller.” Rep. Alan Lowenthal (D-CA) tweeted <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=01f-a5f&t=c>, “The Mueller probe must be allowed to continue without interference. Trump loyalist and acting AG Whitaker must immediately recuse himself. The new House of Representatives will take all necessary action to uphold the Constitution and prevent obstruction of justice.” In an editorial, the Weekly Standard <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=020-dbe&t=c> (11/8) writes that “a president has every right to fire his attorney general and hire one more to his liking, of course,” but “in this instance” Whitaker “has not recused himself from the Mueller probe and has repeatedly questioned its legitimacy.” DOJ “has announced that Whitaker will now oversee the Mueller investigation,” and “there are real questions about whether he can do this – or how.” Harry Litman, US attorney for the Western District of Pennsylvania from 1998 to 2001 and deputy assistant attorney general from 1993 to 1998, writes in the Washington Post <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=021-09a&t=c> (11/8), “Whitaker is a fundamentally political actor,” and “it’s not hard to envision that in some general way, he will have Trump’s back, even though it would be a stark dereliction of duty.” While “it’s a safe bet that he will not seek to fire Mueller or bring the investigation to an immediate close...that leaves a long list of possible mischief that could cripple the probe. ... The threat to Mueller’s ability to complete a comprehensive investigation is material and might yet be mortal.” Max Boot tweeted <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=022-a3d&t=c>, “If R’s cared about their oath of office (I know, an implausible assumption) they would join with Dems to pass legislation protecting Mueller’s independence and threaten Whitaker – and Trump – with impeachment should they attempt to impede the investigation.” Erick Erickson tweeted <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=023-82f&t=c>, “Just to be clear, you can have an acting Attorney General. See e.g. Sally Yates. But you cannot have an acting AG who had not been through a confirmation process for an AG position. Yates was confirmed as a Deputy AG. Whitaker has not.” Politico’s Blake Hounshell tweeted <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=024-6c3&t=c>, “It does not seem like Whitaker was vetted.” Marc Ambinder tweeted <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=025-957&t=c>, “If Trump is getting queasy about Whitaker with a presumed R+5 [Senate] majority... it ain’t gonna get any easier for him in two weeks.” *Conway: Mueller Probe “Will Continue.” *Kellyanne Conway was asked on Fox News[image: Image removed by sender. Video] <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=026-b10&t=c> (11/8) when the decision to fire Sessions was made. Conway said, “The President obviously asked for his resignation yesterday. He tendered it. It has been a fraught relationship that you have covered on your program and also on your network for many months if not the better part of a year and a half. It has been a long time coming. I think many people including the President yesterday commended general sessions for his years of service.” Conway added, “I think it is very commendable and notable that the President is auguring for a continuum by having the chief of staff to the Attorney General, who has been there for over a year on the job, be the acting Attorney General, quote, ‘until a permanent replacement can be nominated,’ and keeping in his job the Deputy Attorney General, Mr. Rosenstein. So this is a continuum. The Mueller investigation will continue.” *Conway’s Husband Claims Whitaker’s Appointment Is “Unconstitutional” And “Illegal.” *Former acting solicitor general Neal Katyal and attorney George Conway, who is married to Kellyanne Conway, argue in an op-ed for the New York Times <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=027-d6f&t=c> (11/8) that the President’s “installation of Matthew Whitaker as acting attorney general of the United States after forcing the resignation of Jeff Sessions is unconstitutional,” and “illegal.” According to Katyal and Conway, “anything Mr. Whitaker does, or tries to do, in that position is invalid.” Katyal and Conway continue, “Constitutionally, Matthew Whitaker is a nobody. His job as Mr. Sessions’s chief of staff did not require Senate confirmation,” and “for the president to install Mr. Whitaker as our chief law enforcement officer is to betray the entire structure of our charter document.” The Washington Examiner <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=028-2c3&t=c> (11/8, Yilek) reports that “one argument in support of the appointment relies on the Federal Vacancies Reform Act of 1998, which says a person may serve ‘no longer than 210 days beginning on the date the vacancy occurs,’ or ‘once a first or second nomination for the office is submitted to the Senate, from the date of such nomination for the period that the nomination is pending in the Senate.’” The Examiner adds that “if the Senate rejects a president’s nominee, then the temporary replacement can serve for another 210-day period.” However, “Conway and Katyal said that argument is flawed, citing the Supreme Court ruling last year that Lafe Solomon improperly served as the general counsel of the National Labor Relations Board because he was not confirmed by the Senate.” USA Today <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=029-24b&t=c> (11/8, Cummings) notes that “Conway, a self-described conservative, has a history of being openly critical of his wife’s boss.” *CBS: Whitaker “Criticized” Trump During 2016 Campaign. *On CBS This Morning[image: Image removed by sender. Video] <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=02a-304&t=c> (11/8), Major Garrett reported that during the 2016 campaign, Whitaker “criticized” Trump. Whitaker was shown saying, “Doesn’t seem right now that anything sticks to him, even being a misogynist.” *Whitaker Questioned High Court Rulings, Judiciary’s Power. *The New York Times <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=02b-547&t=c> (11/8, Savage) reports Whitaker “once espoused the view that the courts ‘are supposed to be the inferior branch’ and criticized the Supreme Court’s power to review legislative and executive acts and declare them unconstitutional, the lifeblood of its existence as a coequal branch of government.” The Times adds that “in a candidate Q. and A. when he sought the Republican nomination for senator in Iowa in 2014, Mr. Whitaker indicated that he shared the view among some conservatives that the federal judiciary has too much power over public policy issues.” Whitaker “criticized many of the Supreme Court’s rulings, starting with a foundational one: Marbury v. Madison, which established its power of judicial review in 1803.” Under the headline “Matthew Whitaker Is A Crackpot,” Ruth Marcus writes in the Washington Post <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=02c-a9f&t=c> (11/8), “Reasonable people can differ over the constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act,” and “maybe there’s some space to debate the New Deal-era cases that cemented the authority of the regulatory state. But Marbury? This is lunacy.” *In 2014 Debate, Whitaker Appeared To Advocate “Biblical View Of Justice.” *The Washington Post <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=02d-120&t=c> (11/8, Boorstein) reports, “In a 2014 debate when he was running for the US Senate,” Whitaker “said judges should have a Christian worldview, and that a judge with a ‘secular worldview’ would be problematic, according to reports from that time.” Whitaker said, “If they have a secular worldview, where this is all we have here on Earth, then I’m going to be very concerned about how they judge. ... I’d like to see things like their world view, what informs them. Are they people of faith? Do they have a biblical view of justice? – which I think is very important.” *Reports: Whitaker Worked For “Scam Firm” That Threatened Victims With Violence. *In a story titled “Trump’s New A.G. Worked For Scam Firm That Threatened Victims With Krav Maga-Style Beatdowns,” Vanity Fair <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=02e-58e&t=c> (11/7, Levin) reports that “it turns out that...in 2014 Whitaker started serving on the advisory board of a company called World Patent Marketing, which bilked inventors out of millions they thought were going toward patents and licensing deals, and was shut down by the Federal Trade Commission last year.” According to Vanity Fair, “Whitaker’s most crucial role was arguably in using his prior work as a federal prosecutor to intimidate people when they realized the company was a scam.” Moreover, “the F.T.C. complaint adds that ‘Defendants also cultivate a threatening atmosphere’ by sending its victims e-mails describing a company ‘security team’ of ‘all ex-Israeli Special Ops and trained in Krav Maga, one of the most deadly of the martial arts.’” The story was initially broken by the Miami New Times <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=02f-649&t=c> (11/8, Shammas), which said “those who lost money in the scam are still waiting to receive any kind of compensation,” and “some were stunned by the choice of Whitaker.” The Washington Post <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=030-11c&t=c> (11/8, Leonnig, Helderman, O'Harrow) reports “Whitaker’s sudden elevation this week to replace...Sessions has put new scrutiny on his involvement with the shuttered company, whose advisory board he joined in 2014, shortly after making a failed run for US Senate in Iowa.” The Post adds that “at the time, he was also running a conservative watchdog group with ties to other powerful nonprofits on the right and was beginning to develop a career as a Trump-friendly cable television commentator.” The New York Times <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=031-507&t=c> (11/8, Goldman, Robles) reports, “Court documents show that when frustrated consumers tried to get their money back, Scott J. Cooper, the company’s president and founder, used Mr. Whitaker to threaten them as a former federal prosecutor. Mr. Cooper’s company paid Mr. Whitaker nearly $10,000 before it closed.” The Times adds “Whitaker’s role in the company would complicate his confirmation prospects should...Trump nominate him as attorney general,” and that “it is not clear if Mr. Trump was aware of Mr. Whitaker’s involvement with the patent marketing company before naming him as a replacement for...Sessions.” Catherine Rampell writes in the Washington Post <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=032-f90&t=c> (11/8, Rampell) that “maybe Whitaker really was picked because he has experience advising con artists.” For his work for Petent Marketing, Whitaker “received $9,375 between 2014 and early 2016,” plus “the company’s chief executive also donated $2,600 to Whitaker’s Senate campaign, and the company owed him an additional $7,500 at the time the FTC moved to seize it.” Rampell conceded that “Whitaker is not personally named in the FTC complaint, and we don’t know the extent of his day-to-day involvement with the company,” but adds, “Given all this, why was Whitaker chosen for an (acting) Cabinet post? Presumably because a Nigerian prince wasn’t available.” Trump “clearly loves to surround himself with fellow hucksters, snake-oil salesmen and others accused of questionable business behavior.” The Washington Post’s Matea Gold tweeted <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=033-d16&t=c>, “Said one former World Patent Marketing customer who lost $77,000 of Whitaker: ‘It’s really upsetting to know that guy will be attorney general. It’s so offensive. It’s like a stab in the back.’” *Sessions Stands By Decision To Recuse Himself But Calls Duration Of Mueller Probe “Unhealthy.” *Interviewed by Judith Miller in the Wall Street Journal <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=034-27e&t=c> (11/8, Miller), Sessions expressed confidence that Mueller’s probe will be handled “appropriately and with justification,” and said that it he had to do it over he would still recuse himself from the investigation because “no one is above supervision.” Sessions also said he did not expect Mueller’s activities to last this long, something he called “unhealthy.” Alabama Live <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=035-280&t=c> (11/8, Gattis) reports, meanwhile, that Sessions used a letter to DOJ staff to tout “some of the DOJ’s achievements during his tenure.” The letter “was reported Thursday in a tweet <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=036-455&t=c> by Buzzfeed reporter Dominic Holden.” Wrote Sessions, “To have led a department like this goes beyond anything I ever would have thought possible. ... If you had told me when I was starting out as a young assistant United States attorney that I would ever serve as attorney general, I don’t think I would have believed you.” *Christie, Giuliani, Bondi, Barr, Brown, Azar Among Those Mentioned For AG Post. *CBS News <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=037-6e9&t=c> (11/8, Garrett) reports on its website that Trump is considering picking former New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie to serve as attorney general. CBS News adds, “No decisions are expected soon, and the list of those being considered – which also includes Rudy Giuliani, outgoing Florida Attorney General Pam Bondi, and former Attorney General William Barr, who served under President George H. W. Bush – is likely to grow in the coming days.” The North Jersey (NJ) Media Group <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=038-2b4&t=c> (11/8, Pugliese, Jackson) reports “Christie visited the White House on Thursday as several news outlets reported that...Trump is considering him.” Christie “said during an interview on Fox News last year that he likely would have resigned as governor had Trump originally offered him the job of attorney general.” According to CNBC <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=039-177&t=c> (11/8, Mangan), Christie’s White House visit was not related to the AG position, but rather it was to meet with Jared Kushner about prison reform. CNN <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=03a-924&t=c> (11/8, Diamond, Westwood) says on its website that “other potential contenders have cropped up in Trump-friendly circles in recent months, including...Solicitor General Noel Francisco, Rep. John Ratcliffe, R-Texas, former Judge John Michael Luttig, Judge Edith Jones, former Judge Janice Rogers Brown, retiring Rep. Trey Gowdy, R-South Carolina and Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-South Carolina.” McClatchy <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=03b-4f0&t=c> (11/8, Kumar, Hall) reported “Trump is seriously considering naming...Brown” to the position, while The Hill <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=03c-070&t=c> (11/8, Wheeler) cites HHS Secretary Azar as a possible nominee and notes Barr responded “no comment” when asked if he’s interested in the position. HHS spokeswoman Caitlin Oakley said of Azar’s future, “He plans to continue serving President Trump as his HHS secretary.” The AP <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=03d-b90&t=c> (11/8, Hanna) reports that Kris Kobach’s “hard-line, in-your-face approach could help him land his next political position, possibly in the Trump administration.” Kobach’s “name immediately popped up Wednesday, after...Sessions was forced to resign,” and “if Trump picks someone else to replace Sessions, Kobach’s name is almost certain to surface again when Trump has another big post to fill.” *Mueller Team Reportedly Drafting Final Report. *The Washington Times <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=03e-1df&t=c> (11/8, Mordock) reports that according to CNN, Mueller’s team “has begun writing its final report on its 18-month Russia investigation.” The probe “has entered its final stages, but federal prosecutors reportedly still have some final pieces to put into place.” The Washington Examiner <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=03f-0dd&t=c> (11/8, Yilek) reports that one of those loose ends is Mueller’s seeking of call and visitor logs related to Roger Stone from Trump Tower. Mueller “is investigating whether Stone had advance knowledge of WikiLeaks’ plans to release hacked emails stolen from Democrats.” *Giuliani Says Trump, Legal Team Will Meet Next Week To Discuss Responses To Mueller. *Politico <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=040-edf&t=c> (11/8, Samuelsohn) reports that President Trump’s attorney Rudy Giuliani said in an interview that the President and his legal team “are planning to meet next week to decide whether to submit any of their written responses” to Mueller. Giuliani said, “I think the only thing that throws us off a little, which we explained to [Mueller], is that the President’s going to be away for about three, four days. ... We really want the President to have a day home where he can just think about it, make sure he’s comfortable with it, and then we’ll tell [Mueller] what the decision is.” *Federal Court Hears Case Over Mueller Appointment. *The AP <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=041-3e7&t=c> (11/8, Day) reports that a three-judge panel of the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia heard arguments Thursday in a case brought by former Stone aide Andrew Miller about whether Mueller’s “appointment to lead the Russia investigation was constitutional. ... At issue is whether Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein had the authority to appoint Mueller. The special counsel’s office says yes. But lawyers for Miller say no.” Politico <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=042-3e8&t=c> (11/8, Gerstein, Meyer, Samuelsohn) reports that one of the judges, George H.W. Bush appointee Karen Henderson, said the court would not immediately consider the departure of Jeff Sessions as attorney general in the case, but “signaled that the developments might well impact the legal issues around Mueller’s authority.” Laurence Tribe tweeted <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=043-b9a&t=c>, “So strange to see the legality of Mueller’s mandate argued in the DC Circuit the day after the legally dubious installation of Matt Whitaker to oversee Mueller after he publicly called Mueller’s probe a Lynch mob.” Foreign Policy Haley: North Korea Postponed Pompeo Meeting. Reuters <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=044-f74&t=c> (11/8, Nichols) reports UN Ambassador Haley said that North Korean officials postponed a meeting with Secretary of State Pompeo previously scheduled for this week “because they weren’t ready.” Haley added, “Secretary Pompeo was ready to come. We continue to stand ready to talk but I don’t think that there was some major issue.” The AP <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=045-ba9&t=c> (11/9, Lederer) reports Haley also said that she believes the talks between Pompeo and Kim Yong Chol are going to be rescheduled, and added, “And it doesn’t change the fact that that summit is still scheduled for the President and Kim to meet after the first of the year.” *Markey Urges Trump To Stop Keeping American Aid Workers From North Korea. *The New York Times <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=046-ddd&t=c> (11/8, Wong) reports Sen. Edward Markey (D-MA) wrote to President Trump, Pompeo, and Treasury Secretary Mnuchin saying he is “deeply troubled” that the Administration is reportedly barring aid workers “from shipping supplies or traveling to North Korea as they seek to provide the most basic humanitarian assistance.” Markey said in a statement to the Times that American interests “are best served when our moral and global leadership are in lock step.” Saudis Ignoring US Ceasefire Calls As Fighting Threatens Hundreds Of Thousands Of Yemenis. The Washington Post <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=047-0c3&t=c> (11/8, Raghavan) reports that “despite U.S. calls for a cease-fire, fighting is escalating in a strategic Yemeni port city, threatening the lives of hundreds of thousands of civilians and deepening a humanitarian crisis in which millions are at risk from a looming famine.” According to the Post, “The clashes in Hodeida, pitting a U.S.-backed regional coalition led by Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates against northern Houthi rebels, have caused numerous civilian casualties over the past week,” and “the violence is also edging closer to medical facilities, threatening the safety of patients and medical workers.” The Post says “the fighting has particularly intensified near Hodeida’s port, through which passes more than 70 percent of all food, fuel, medicine and other essential supplies destined for the northern part of the country, where the large majority of Yemenis live.” *Johnson: Saudis’ War In Yemen Is Actually Strengthening Iran’s Influence In The Region. *Former British foreign minister Boris Johnson, in an op-ed for the Washington Post <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=048-7f3&t=c> (11/8), writes, “The war in Yemen is turning out to be bad for Saudi Arabia – and, alas, is boosting, not reversing, Iranian influence.” Johnson says the Iranian government “had virtually no influence in Yemen at all, and no real strategic interest, until the Saudi-led coalition began its ill-fated campaign of aerial bombardments against the Houthi rebels.” Johnson adds, “In the three years since the Saudis launched their offensive, Yemen has been brought to the brink of starvation – and the Houthis have been driven so far into the arms of Iran that in the past year they have actually started firing Iranian-built missiles at Saudi Arabia.” According to Johnson, “That is why it was right that last week” both Defense Secretary Mattis and Secretary of State Pompeo “decided to increase the pressure on Saudi Arabia. We need a cease-fire.” *US-Backed Sunni “Security Alliance” In Jeopardy Amid Infighting And Concern About Khashoggi Murder. *Reuters <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=049-a42&t=c> (11/8, Landay, Bayoumy) reports that President Trump’s “strategy to contain Iranian power in the Middle East by forging Arab allies into a U.S.-backed security alliance was in trouble even before the murder of Saudi journalist Jamal Khashoggi,” and “now...the plan faces fresh complications.” Reuters says the Middle East Strategic Alliance “aims to bind Sunni Muslim governments...to counter Shi’ite Iran,” but “feuds among Arab allies, especially a Saudi-led economic and political boycott of Qatar, have hampered the founding of the alliance since Riyadh proposed it last year.” According to Reuters, “a summit meeting in the United States where Trump and the Arab leaders would sign a preliminary accord on the alliance was expected in January,” but now “meeting now looks uncertain.” US Reportedly Considering Designating Houthis A Terrorist Organization. The Washington Post <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=04a-4b9&t=c> (11/8, Ryan) reports people familiar with the discussions said that “as part of a campaign to end” the Yemen civil war and put pressure on Iran, the Administration “is considering designating Yemen’s Houthi rebels a terrorist organization,” as part of “an array of potential actions against the rebels, including lesser measures to sanction the group.” Going forward with a terrorist designation “would be seen as a major escalation of U.S. pressure against the group” and “would inject an unpredictable new element into fragile diplomatic efforts to initiate peace talks.” Some US officials have resisted such a mvoe believing it “might complicate U.N. negotiators’ efforts to get peace discussions off the ground.” It also could “worsen already dire humanitarian conditions without pushing the conflict closer to a conclusion.” US Announces More Sanctions Over Russia’s Actions In Ukraine. The AP <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=04b-2c2&t=c> (11/8) reports the US “slapped sanctions on three individuals and nine entities over what it said was Russia’s ‘malign’ activity in Crimea and eastern Ukraine.” In a statement, Treasury Department Undersecretary for Terrorism and Financial Intelligence Sigal Mandelker said those affected were targeted “for serious human rights abuses” and furthering the “Russian occupation of Crimea and use of force” in eastern Ukraine. Reuters <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=04c-340&t=c> (11/8, Ahmann, Brice, Wroughton) reports Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov called the sanctions unacceptable and predicted they would not influence Russia, TASS news agency reported. The Washington Times <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=04d-704&t=c> (11/8, Boylan) also covers this story. *Bipartisan Group Of Foreign Policy Experts Urge Trump Not To Scrap US-Russia Nuclear Deal. *The New York Times <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=04e-ff0&t=c> (11/8, Gladstone) reports that “a bipartisan array of American nonproliferation experts” who are “alarmed at what they see as disintegrating curbs on nuclear weapons” have “urged President Trump to salvage a Cold War-era treaty with Russia that he has vowed to scrap.” According to the Times, “In letters sent to the White House this week...the experts said the pact, the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty, had reduced the risk of nuclear war,” and made the case that, “despite the treaty’s flaws...the United States should work to fix the accord, not walk away from it.” Among those who signed the letter are former secretary of state George Schultz and former Sens. Richard Lugar and Sam Nunn. *WPost Condemns Russian Move Against Magazine. *In an editorial, the Washington Post <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=04f-a8e&t=c> (11/8) condemns a Russian court’s “unprecedented” fine on the New Times, “a rare oasis in a sea of state-controlled pablum.” The magazine, which “looks critically at the Kremlin and its web of power,” could have to stop operations should the fine be enforced. The Post condemns the move as “a pretext for an attack on independent journalism. “ Reuters Analysis: US Isolation Will Soften Impact Of Renewed Sanctions On Iran. Reuters <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=050-18a&t=c> (11/8, Hafezi, Saul) reports that “officials and analysts” believe that the Iranian economy “is likely to ride out the storm from U.S. oil sanctions, suffering recession but no economic meltdown, thanks to rising crude prices and deepening divisions between the United States and other major powers. ... ‘Iran’s situation is better than pre-2016 because of high oil prices and the fact that the U.S. is isolated this time,’ said a European diplomat who asked not to be further identified.” Reuters says “the other signatories to the nuclear deal – Germany, France, Britain, the European Union, Russia and China – have condemned Trump’s walkout from the pact,” and the EU is “preparing a special mechanism to enable payments for Iranian oil and other exports without U.S. dollars.” *New US Sanctions Don’t Cover Half Of Firms Under Control Of Iranian Security Forces. *The Washington Free Beacon <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=051-8ce&t=c> (11/8, Kredo) reports that a Foundation for Defense of Democracies analysis found that the US sanctions on Iran that came into effect on Monday do not cover “half of the publicly listed firms under the principal control of the regime’s security forces.” The Free Beacon predicts, “The failure of the new sanctions to hit these key sources of funding for the hardline Iranian regime is likely to provide further grist to Iran hawks in Congress and their allies who have expressed frustration over what they say is the Trump administration’s failure to uphold its vow to fully sanction Iran and choke off the regime’s primary funding sources.” Democrats Set To Demand To Know What Trump Has Said To Putin And Kim. The Washington Post <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=052-ba0&t=c> (11/8, Morello) reports that House Democrats say they intend to “take a closer look at” President Trump’s “private conversations with world leaders, overseas business entanglements and the purge of diplomats from the State Department.” According to the Post, “The Democrats’ wish list includes hearings advancing alternatives to White House policies on climate change, refugees and migration.” In addition, the Post says Democrats “want to find out what Trump said to Russian President Vladimir Putin at a July meeting in Helsinki unattended by any White House aides, and what he told North Korea’s Kim Jong Un when they met with only interpreters present during a summit in Singapore.” US Destroyer Nearly Collided With A Chinese Warship In September. The New York Times <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=053-495&t=c> (11/8, Perlez, Myers) reports that on September 30, a Chinese warship “raced up alongside” the Decatur, an American destroyer, “getting perilously close.” Only a sharp turn by the Decatur “avoided a disaster,” and “the ships came within 45 yards of each other, marking the closest call yet as the United States Navy contests China’s military buildup in the South China Sea.” With China deploying more planes and ships in an effort “to challenge American dominance in the region, such encounters may become more frequent.” Analysts say that “the lack of an agreement between China and the United States on the rules of the game in the South China Sea raises the risk of a deadly mishap.” Defense Secretary Mattis and Chinese Defense Minister Wei Fenghe “are expected to make an effort to calm those rising tensions and reduce the risks of miscalculation when they meet in Washington on Friday.” *Rogin: US Needs Funds To Back Efforts To Challenge Chinese Economic Regional Dominance. *Josh Rogin, in column in the Washington Post <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=054-f9d&t=c> (11/8), writes Vice President Pence’s Asia trip “comes at a crucial juncture,” with “economics...emerging as the key battleground in the greater competition between China and the world’s democracies over who will decide the regional and world order for the next decades.” At the upcoming Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) leaders meeting, “Pence will lay out the next phase of the Trump administration’s ever evolving Asia strategy” in an effort “to put meat on the bone of” Trump’s Asia strategy and argue “that the United States and its allies can offer them better options than capitulation to Chinese economic regional dominance.” However, US “counterproposals have been light on actual resources,” and many Southeast Asian nations remain “sore about Trump exiting the Trans-Pacific Partnership.” Rogin concludes, “the United States must put its money where its mouth is.” Domestic Policy Afghanistan Veteran Kills 12 In California Bar Before Killing Himself. All three broadcast networks devoted significant time on their Thursday evening newscasts to the mass shooting at a bar in Thousand Oaks, California, where a 28-year-old Marine veteran who served in Afghanistan killed 12 people before killing himself. On Thursday morning, President Trump tweeted <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=055-b5f&t=c>, “I have been fully briefed on the terrible shooting in California. Law Enforcement and First Responders, together with the FBI, are on scene. 13 people, at this time, have been reported dead. Likewise, the shooter is dead, along with the first police officer to enter the bar.” The President then tweeted <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=056-7e1&t=c>, “Great bravery shown by police. California Highway Patrol was on scene within 3 minutes, with first officer to enter shot numerous times. That Sheriff’s Sergeant died in the hospital. God bless all of the victims and families of the victims. Thank you to Law Enforcement.” David Muir opened ABC World News Tonight[image: Image removed by sender. Video] <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=057-b3d&t=c> (11/8, lead story, 4:00) by saying, “You probably woke up this morning like so many in this country, saying, ‘not again.’ We are here in Thousand Oaks, California, the scene of the nation’s newest mass shooting. ... The shots ringing out, people hiding wherever they could...carrying the injured as they ran. Police rushing to the scene, heavily armed officers, including a police sergeant who was among the first to go in. That sheriff’s sergeant did not survive.” Lester Holt opened NBC Nightly News[image: Image removed by sender. Video] <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=058-c44&t=c> (11/8, lead story, 1:30) with a similar tone, saying, “America, here we are again, seeking answers to the same old questions after lives are stolen in another senseless rampage. ... Families once again grieving the sudden, unimaginable loss of their loved ones, and before we get to anything else, we want you to hear from a father in the kind of gut-wrenching anguish no parent should ever know.” On the CBS Evening News[image: Image removed by sender. Video] <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=059-353&t=c> (11/8, lead story, 4:00), Jeff Glor reported, “The shooter was a Marine combat veteran who is believed to have killed himself after taking 12 lives.” The Los Angeles Times <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=05a-57b&t=c> (11/8, Greene) reports that the gunman, Ian David Long, was “a former U.S. Marine machine gunner who may have suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder.” He entered the Borderline Bar and Grill, “tossed a smoke bomb into the crowd and opened fire, authorities said.” The bar “was hosting line-dancing lessons for college students as young as 18 on Wednesday night. Crowds of young people, including parties for two women celebrating their 21st birthdays, were drinking and dancing when the crack of gunfire echoed through the cavernous room about 11:20 p.m.” The Thousand Oaks (CA) Acorn <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=05b-54c&t=c> (11/8, Jorrey) reports that “an estimated 175 people” were inside the bar, “including students from surrounding colleges Cal Lutheran University, Pepperdine University, Cal State Channel Islands and Moorpark College.” The Malibu (CA) Times <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=05c-032&t=c> (11/8, Shivani Patel /, Writer) reports that Long’s gun, “legally purchased, was identified as a .45-caliber Glock 21 designed in California to hold 10 rounds. The gunman had illegally purchased and added an extended magazine for more rounds.” On the CBS Evening News[image: Image removed by sender. Video] <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=05d-61f&t=c> (11/8, story 4, 2:00, Glor), John Blackstone reported, “Hours after the mass shooting, ATF and FBI investigators raided the house where Ian Long lived with his mother, on a suburban street about five miles from the Borderline Bar. In his mother’s neighborhood, those who lived nearby say he seemed to be frequently angry and unfriendly.” Gareth Crites, neighbor: “He wouldn’t come out of the house that much, and when I did see him drive by, I’d wave at him, he would not wave back.” On NBC Nightly News[image: Image removed by sender. Video] <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=05e-cff&t=c> (11/8, story 5, 1:30, Holt), Tom Costello reported, “The first indications police had that Ian Long might be violent came last April when his family reported a domestic disturbance. ... Though deemed not to be a threat, deputies thought he might be suffering from PTSD.” The Ventura County (CA) Star <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=05f-732&t=c> (11/8, Stanglin, Curley, Woodyard, Kisken) reports, “Often, neighbors could hear Long, his mother and sometimes a third person yelling in arguments that erupted at all times of the day, sometimes ‘in the middle of night.’” One neighbor said, “No question in my mind that the guy was troubled.” Another said, “Everyone knew he had PTSD.” Other national media framed the story in the context of what Glor on the CBS Evening News[image: Image removed by sender. Video] <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=060-06b&t=c> (11/8, stroy 10, 1:40) called “an American epidemic” of mass shootings. Holt said on NBC Nightly News[image: Image removed by sender. Video] <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=061-226&t=c> (11/8, story 6, 1:30), “Less than two weeks ago, we were reporting from the scene of another mass shooting in Pittsburgh. In fact, folks, there has been a mass shooting almost every day this year.” On ABC World News Tonight[image: Image removed by sender. Video] <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=062-666&t=c> (11/8, story 10, 0:40), Muir referred to “the images seen far too often across America, from Las Vegas to Parkland to the Pittsburgh synagogue, less than two weeks ago. And now, here in Thousand Oaks.” The New York Times <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=063-6b8&t=c> (11/8, Real, Medina, Arango) reports, “The attack is only the latest in a wave of mass shootings that have plagued the country this year. A man opened fire at a Pittsburgh synagogue late last month, killing 11 people in an attack that officials said was motivated by anti-Semitism and anti-immigrant rage. This week, the nation paused for one day to vote, and then, more violence.” The Washington Post <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=064-d36&t=c> (11/8, Fahrenthold) writes that “for many of those inside” the bar, “there was a grim benefit to being young in America during an age of massacres: They knew exactly what this was, and they knew exactly what to do, in the way that past generations knew how to hide from tornadoes or nuclear bombs.” The AP <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=065-9f2&t=c> (11/8, Fauria) and Reuters <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=066-6d3&t=c> (11/8, Dobuzinskis) also report. The New York Times <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=067-572&t=c> (11/8) editorializes, “Americans are watching – and now some are even experiencing – versions of this same horror over and over, hoping that someone will eventually figure out how to break the cycle. Could that hero be President Trump and the House Democrats? Perhaps.” The Times calls Trump “the ideal president to tackle the issue. He enjoys the adoration of his party’s culturally conservative base to a degree few politicians even approach. If inclined, he could burn just a small fraction of that capital on promoting some of the common-sense gun measures desired by a majority of the electorate.” The Washington Post <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=068-728&t=c> (11/8) editorializes, “Gun violence is a national emergency and a public-health crisis – a crisis that could be ameliorated, without depriving anyone of their constitutional rights, if the nation chose to take it seriously. Hopefully – if Tuesday’s midterm elections are any indication – that finally may begin to happen. There has been a shift in the politics of gun control; no longer is it a third rail to be avoided at all costs.” USA Today <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=069-ecd&t=c> (11/8, Board, Today) editorializes, “Politicians, particularly at the federal level, could respond to these killings with common-sense gun laws that establish universal background checks and ban assault-style rifles and high-capacity magazines. ... But Congress remains paralyzed when it comes to sensibly limiting the nation’s growing arsenal of firearms and mass-killing accessories.” Gun Owners of America Executive Director Erich Pratt writes in a responding USA Today <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=06a-522&t=c> (11/8) op-ed, “Once again, we see the failure of gun control in preventing a horrible tragedy. Wednesday’s California bar shooting was in a gun-free zone, where good guys cannot legally carry firearms.” Ginsburg Hospitalized As Kavanaugh Is Welcomed To Supreme Court. The AP <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=06b-83a&t=c> (11/8, Sherman) reports that Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, 85, “fractured three ribs in a fall in her office at the court and is in the hospital.” Ginsburg “called Supreme Court police to take her to George Washington University Hospital in Washington early Thursday after experiencing discomfort overnight.” The AP adds, “In her absence, the court went ahead Thursday with a courtroom ceremony welcoming new Justice Brett Kavanaugh, who joined the court last month.” The AP notes that President Trump and acting Attorney General Matthew Whitaker were at the ceremony. The Washington Post <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=06c-dc6&t=c> (11/8, Barnes) says that “in a reminder of the controversy surrounding Kavanaugh’s nomination, he skipped the traditional walk down the Supreme Court steps with the chief justice, where new members for decades have had their photos taken by a waiting throng of news photographers.” The Post says a court spokeswoman “cited security concerns.” The New York Times <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=06d-193&t=c> (11/8, Landler) describes Kavanaugh’s formal welcome as “solemn, dignified and brief – the antithesis of the prolonged, bitter, circuslike spectacle that preceded it,” but adds “there were still echoes of the rancor his nomination to the court ignited.” According to the New York Times <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=06e-3a9&t=c> (11/8, Sullivan), “The next sitting of the Supreme Court begins Nov. 26, and...Ginsburg’s history suggests the injuries are not likely to keep her away.” The CBS Evening News[image: Image removed by sender. Video] <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=06f-bae&t=c> (11/8, story 7, 1:55, Crawford) said “liberals for years have worried about her health and retirement,” and NBC Nightly News[image: Image removed by sender. Video] <http://mailview.bulletinintelligence.com/mailview.aspx?m=2018110901biden&r=email-bac8&l=070-1
METADATA:
THREAD:
INDEX:
AQNaHNV+9VrAqtJ3hB0zau/xKti07qI8N3AQ
REFERENCES:
REPLY_TO:
<0.0.0.65.1D4782C08E37DAF.0@colo033.bulletinnews.com>
REFS:
<0.0.0.65.1D4782C08E37DAF.0@colo033.bulletinnews.com>